Multiple people in Savannah arrested on RICO, shoplifting charges

by Madalyn Bierster, Steven Glover

SAVANNAH, Ga. (WTOC) - [UPDATE 11/19/2026] Another man was arrested in connection to a multi-state organized retail crime investigation.

Eugene Sibert, 54 was arrested Thursday, Nov. 19 on two counts of Violation of Georgia’s RICO act and Robbery. He joins 10 others as part of a multi-state organized retail crime investigation. He’s currently being held at the Effingham County Jail, but was moved to Chatham County temporarily for court.

He’s part of an ongoing case brought on by the Attorney General’s office, with an 87 page indictment with multiple allegations.

All 11 defendants in this case have an arraignment on Friday, Nov. 20 in the case.

[UPDATE 9/18/2026] A multi-state organized retail theft ring tied to Chatham County continues to expand, with state prosecutors announcing eight more individuals have been indicted under Georgia’s Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) Act.

The new grand jury indictment, secured by Georgia Attorney General Chris Carr’s Organized Retail Crime Unit, brings the total number of defendants charged in the enterprise to 11 following an initial announcement of three suspects earlier this week.

Authorities allege the group orchestrated a large-scale criminal enterprise dating back to October 2022 that targeted 10 major retail brands across Georgia, Florida, South Carolina, and Virginia, resulting in more than $200,000 in stolen merchandise.

The Defendants

The eight newly named defendants, all facing RICO charges alongside additional theft offenses, include:

  • Shawntavius Shanell Butler (aka “TayTay” or “Tay”), 31, of Savannah
  • Rashamel Okuise Gardner (aka “Rara” or “Ralis”), 33, of Savannah
  • Eugene Edward Sibert (aka “Hawk”), 54, of Savannah
  • Lakytra Marie Gardner (aka “KeKe” or “Ke”), 37, of Savannah
  • Deaunbrey Antonio Gardner (aka “Antonio” or “Tonio”), 51, of Savannah
  • Zyquie Hakeem Gardner (aka “Zy”), 26, of Savannah
  • Javari Javontay Romain Larry (aka “Lil One” or “Fed”), 24, of Savannah
  • Shi’heed Ja’mill Small (aka “Shi,” “Shy,” or “Shii”), 26, of Savannah

They join three defendants previously identified in the indictment: Jasmonique Lavon Franklin, 35, of Pooler; Dominique A. Giles, Jr., 19, of Savannah; and Cedric Latroy Gardner, 33, of Savannah.

How the Scheme Operated

According to prosecutors, the enterprise engaged in a coordinated pattern of shoplifting, snatch-and-grab robberies, and illicit online resale operations over a four-year period.

The group targeted stores in 11 Georgia counties—including Chatham, Bulloch, Glynn, and Liberty—as well as locations throughout Florida, South Carolina, and Virginia. Targeted retailers included:

  • The Home Depot
  • Walmart
  • Ulta Beauty
  • Floor & Decor
  • Bath & Body Works
  • Luxottica of America (Sunglass Hut)
  • DTLR
  • Sterling Jewelers (Kay Jewelers)
  • Signet Jewelers (Zales)
  • Great American Jewelers

Investigators allege the defendants stole a wide variety of items, including flooring, paint, household fixtures, power tools, small appliances, electronics, clothing, designer cologne and perfume, and luxury sunglasses.

The operation also involved snatch-and-grab robberies at retail jewelry counters, where suspects made off with solid gold necklaces, bracelets, diamond rings, and Rolex watches.

Once stolen, prosecutors say members of the group advertised and resold the merchandise directly on Instagram.

Multi-Agency Investigation

The case was investigated by the Attorney General’s Organized Retail Crime Unit alongside the Savannah Police Department, Chatham County Police Department, Pooler Police Department, Garden City Police Department, and more than a dozen municipal, state, and federal law enforcement agencies across the Southeast. Private asset protection teams from several of the victimized retail chains also assisted.

“Organized retail crime poses a significant threat to our state, leading to billions in lost revenue, thousands of lost jobs, and increased violence against employees,” Attorney General Chris Carr said in a statement. “If you target our retailers, we’re coming for you, and we will ensure that you’re prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law.”

Savannah Police Chief Lenny Gunther commended the regional teamwork, calling the indictment a testament to the collaboration between local officers and state partners.

In addition to two counts each of violating the state RICO Act, individual defendants face varying charges including theft by shoplifting, theft by receiving stolen property, and robbery.

Royce Abbott
Royce Abbott

Advisor License ID: 438255

+1(912) 438-9043 | royce.abbottjr@engelvoelkers.com

GET MORE INFORMATION

Name
Phone*
Message