Judge: Original Alex Murdaugh murder indictments will not be dismissed

LEXINGTON, S.C. (WCSC) — The original murder charges against Alex Murdaugh will not be dismissed, and the retrial will proceed.
The decision made by Judge Debra McCaslin came on Friday, a week after Murdaugh’s last pretrial hearing, where McCaslin stated she needed time to review information that was presented before coming to a decision.
In the filing, McCaslin stated that Murdaugh’s legal team “did not establish intentional prosecutorial or investigative misconduct that compromised the integrity of the grand jury proceedings.”
Murdaugh’s attorneys had argued the original murder indictment against him was obtained using false and misleading evidence by state investigators.
His legal team’s main stance surrounded former lead State Law Enforcement Division Investigator David Owen, who they claim lied in his testimony to the Colleton County Grand Jury. Murdaugh’s defense claimed Owen lied about blood that was allegedly found on Murdaugh’s shirt and shell casings found on the crime scene.
State prosecutors denied the allegations. The state argued that Owen presented what he knew to be true at the time to the grand jury, which is allowed under state law even if that information was found to be incorrect at a later date.
The state also claimed the evidence on the shirt is not false, and their expert stands by it as well, and the mixed gunshot loads found on the crime scene are supported by evidence.
In McCaslin’s decision, she stated, “even if the challenged testimony concerning the blood spatter on the T-shirt and shotgun ammunition were excluded from consideration by the Grand Jury, the remaining unchallenged evidence overwhelmingly established probable cause.”
Murdaugh’s retrial is still expected to begin in April 2027.
Recent Posts










