Federal officials spent at least a year assessing the Savannah College of Art and Design’s Clery Act compliance

SAVANNAH, Ga. (WTOC) - From November 2023 to at least January 2025, the U.S. Department of Education conducted an assessment of whether the Savannah College of Art and Design (SCAD) complied with the Clery Act, WTOC Investigates has uncovered.
SCAD says it is unaware of any ongoing Clery Group assessment or investigation.
WTOC Investigates confirmed with three former SCAD students and two former employees that they were interviewed by the Clery Group, a special department that monitors whether college campuses are in compliance with the Clery Act. The focus of the interviews, according to our sources, was related to SCAD’s handling of alleged sexual assault and misconduct reports. It is not clear what parts of the law federal officials believed might have been violated.
What the Clery Act requires
The Clery Act imposes a variety of obligations on colleges and universities receiving federal student aid. They must accurately report campus crime statistics and safety data, including data related to alleged sexual assault. The law also requires schools to provide certain resources to victims of violence, including telling victims in writing about their rights, like moving dorms or changing classes, and getting counseling and legal help.
Schools also have to teach students and employees how to spot warning signs and step in. Any campus disciplinary hearing has to be fair and impartial for everyone involved.
The Department of Education oversees the “Clery Group,” a unit dedicated to making sure campuses are in compliance with the law.
S. Daniel Carter, president of Safe Campuses LLC, is a campus safety expert with more than 30 years in the field. He works with colleges and universities to help make sure they are in compliance with the Clery Act, and has submitted both written and in-person testimony to Congress on campus safety issues.
Carter said when the Department of Education opens this kind of review, known as an assessment, it is because the department has reason to believe the rules may have been broken.
“For them to open an assessment is a significant statement,” Carter said. “Before the Department of Education historically would even open an assessment, you essentially have to prove that there’s a strong likelihood that there are Clery Act violations present.”
An assessment is a precursor to what is known as a Program Review, a comprehensive federal compliance investigation that can result in heavy fines against a college. Not every assessment escalates into a Program Review.
Emails show assessment was ‘still ongoing’
WTOC Investigates also reviewed emails between four of the five sources and Clery compliance officials. In November 2024, a Clery compliance official said the Clery Group’s assessment of SCAD was “still ongoing.” In an email dated January 2025, the same official said there were no updates on the status of that assessment.
Speaking generally, Carter said interviews are part of how assessments proceed.
“It is a second level to most assessments, which first involve reviewing documents and requesting written answers from institutional personnel,” Carter said. “Actual interviews is like the next step that they take to begin further assessing a situation.”
Carter said how an assessment unfolds can vary from case to case. In some cases, compliance officials may conduct interviews before reaching out to the school.
SCAD says it is not aware of any ongoing Clery Act assessment or investigation. It says it has not been contacted by the Clery Group since 2022 for an unrelated assessment, which according to SCAD did not result in any findings. SCAD says that assessment was related to SCAD’s emergency notification process, and that the school provided “all the necessary information and did not receive any additional questions or meeting requests.”
Former students and professor describe their interviews
Téa Lynor
Former student Téa Lynor spoke with Clery Group officials in May 2024. She described to them that in 2019 she was sexually harassed by her professor, and that at one point he aggressively grabbed her by the arm.
Asked what she thought when the Department of Education reached out to her, Lynor said:
“Oh, I knew it was bad. I think for the Department of Education, for a federal institution to get involved in an investigation into your school, you almost think, I am definitely not the worst one.”
Lynor says a first-year professor’s behavior pushed her to file a Title IX complaint against him. She says there were serious red flags before she made the report, with the professor singling her out in class to the point other students noticed.
He then asked to meet with her privately, adding a winky face to the end of his email. Lynor was asked what her initial thought was when she read that line and saw how it ended.
“I was super grossed out,” Lynor said. “There was no reason to meet with me. I wasn’t doing badly in his class.”
Lynor said things escalated from there, as she claimed the professor continued to single her out, accusing her in a group email of causing other students to miss class and asking her to call his personal phone to talk about it. Lynor did not respond. Her male classmate did instead.
She says the professor’s behavior did not stop at uncomfortable emails and public favoritism. In one case, it became physical.
“He grabbed my arm and asked if he could speak to me,” Lynor said. “I said okay. He did not let go of my arm the entire time and started pulling me down the hallway.”
Samantha White, Lynor’s classmate, witnessed the incident.
SCAD’s internal investigation report says another student did see the professor hold Lynor’s arm, saying it was not aggressive but still considered it inappropriate.
Lynor says the incident was the deciding factor in reporting the professor to SCAD’s Title IX office, which investigates reports of sexual assault and harassment. Though the incident was not sexual, Lynor viewed it through the lens of the professor’s past behavior, which she considered sexual harassment.
Title IX does not require a single act to be inherently sexual to count as harassment. It also looks at whether unwanted conduct, based on sex, is enough to create a hostile environment.
“After I had made my report, I had had another class with, with him. he stands in front of my desk and he just stares at me,” Lynor said. “And it, it was so unbelievably intimidating, or he was trying to intimidate me, but it was so creepy and malicious. He did not say anything until I finally said, ‘what?’ then he just didn’t say anything and he just smiled and left.”
White, a former SCAD student and Lynor’s classmate, also described the interaction.
“You could tell he was actively trying to intimidate her and, like, stand over her,” White said. “And it was just, like, really, really creepy, icky to, like, watch.”
Based on that interaction, Lynor suspected the professor knew she had reported him.
Emails show Lynor spoke to multiple departments outside of Title IX, including SCAD Human Resources, after Title IX determined it did not “have reasonable cause to activate the grievance process.”
The only person Lynor says she believes really cared was the dean of another department, whom she reached out to as a last resort.
Emails provided to WTOC Investigates by a source close to the situation show at least two other students also had claims about the professor. The basis of the claims is not clear, and it is not clear what was done about them.
SCAD Human Resources ultimately told Lynor after its investigation that “appropriate action” was taken against the professor, but did not say specify what that was. The professor still teaches at SCAD. Asked whether that surprises her, Lynor said, “No.”
A source close to the situation added that “SCAD’s Title IX Office carefully reviewed the complaint in 2019 and determined that the allegations did not fall under the university’s Title IX policy,” and that “the matter was referred to the university’s Compliance Office and Human Resources for investigation under SCAD’s applicable policies.”
Anonymous former student
A former SCAD student spoke to the Clery Group a month after Lynor about her experience with the school. WTOC Investigates is protecting her identity because she fears retaliation and says she is a rape survivor. The Clery Group contacted her in 2024, and emails reviewed by WTOC Investigates show she told officials her story about incidents before 2020.
“I actually did talk to the Department of Education. I did a very similar interview with you as I did with them,” the former student said. “They found out about my case and they called me, which was a crazy phone call to hear from them.”
Scott Sworts
Scott Sworts, a former SCAD professor, spoke to Clery compliance officials in August 2024. He told them that in 2009, the school asked him to keep two students in a hands-on studio class separate after one accused the other of sexual misconduct. Sworts said the school did not report the situation to police.
Sworts, then an architecture professor, says he was put in a situation that was unfair and unsafe to him and his students when one of his students accused another of sexual harassment and stalking. He found out about it when he was pulled into a meeting with SCAD officials.
“I asked, ‘Well, have we reported this to the police?’ ‘No, we’re not going to report this to police. This is an internal matter,’” Sworts said.
With no report to police, Sworts was tasked with keeping the students apart. He says that was a particularly difficult task in a hands-on studio class environment that also required overnight trips to Florida.
“It becomes very challenging for me to be able to 24/7, make sure that the student is safe,” Sworts said. “This is far beyond anything that any faculty member should ever be asked to do. And again, why are you not taking this to the police? Why are there not charges being filed?”
Sworts said he posed that same question to Clery compliance officials during his interview.
“They asked me for some details about what the university did, which was essentially nothing,” Sworts said. “How I managed the situation in, in the classroom, which was basically, you know, I just tried to watch them both like a hawk while still doing my other work.”
SCAD says it has no documentation of any conversation between Sworts and school officials about his allegations, and can’t verify what may have happened.
Asked about when it reports sexual misconduct complaints to law enforcement, SCAD said it “has always taken this responsibility seriously and has continuously updated its policies and procedures as necessary and operates in strict compliance with all Title IX requirements.”
Status of the assessment is unclear
It has been more than two years since the interviews with the Clery Group took place. The five people interviewed about SCAD say they have not heard anything about the assessment, and it is not known why.
The status of the assessment, whether it is still open or has been closed with no finding of non-compliance with the Clery Act, remains unclear. The Department of Education may have concluded there was not sufficient evidence of the law being broken, and closed the assessment.
Since November 2024, the date of one of the last contacts Clery Group officials had with one of the sources, in which an official indicated the assessment was still ongoing, the Trump administration has cut staffing at the Department of Education by nearly 50 percent. A June 2026 report by the Department of Education and the Office of the Inspector General shows the Clery Group was not impacted by the cuts. A lawsuit filed by the State of New York against the department in 2025 says Clery Group staffers were assigned to cover the job responsibilities of people who had been laid off for at least 120 days, putting their own job responsibilities on hold.
A 2025 Department of Education organizational chart shows the department has 11 staff members. WTOC Investigates found at least one of the staff members involved in the assessment of SCAD is no longer with the Clery Group.
The last contact any of the sources had with the Clery Group was less than three weeks before President Donald Trump’s inauguration.
WTOC Investigates reached out to the Department of Education multiple times to ask what the status of the assessment is, but has not heard back.
SCAD told WTOC Investigates that based on its last communication with the Clery Group and its current understanding, it is not under assessment or investigation. Carter said it is possible a school could be under assessment without knowing it.
“I would not read a drop-off in communication as anything on the merits pro or con,” Carter said. “It doesn’t indicate that they found nothing and moved on. It doesn’t indicate that they found something and put it on hold. It doesn’t indicate anything.”
Court documents show alleged scholarship offer tied to confidentiality agreement
New reporting, including court documents obtained by WTOC Investigates, shows SCAD allegedly offered a $36,000 scholarship to a student in exchange for his silence after the student reported an alleged rape in 2017.
WTOC Investigates spoke with Isaac Payne, the former head coach of SCAD’s now-defunct fishing team. In court documents, Payne’s lawyers say he reported an alleged rape by two members of the team to the school. The student who Payne says reported the assault to him was handed a confidentiality agreement. SCAD denies that Payne reported the incident to the school.
Payne’s time at SCAD
For Payne, SCAD was not just his employer. It was first his home, for years.
“I wish I didn’t have to have that experience on the employee side,” Payne said. “If I just had the student experience, I would say it would have been excellent.”
Payne served in the United States Marines for eight years and used his Post-9/11 GI Bill to attend SCAD, where he started a club fishing team. When he had the chance to stay on campus as head coach of the school’s first competitive program, including the first all-women’s team at a university, he jumped at it.
“I was excited because fishing was my passion and something I love,” Payne said. “It still is my passion, something I love to do. It was more about the kids and caring more about making sure I could be the best person I could be for them.”
His work as the team’s head coach earned him a write-up in Game & Fish magazine, and several of his boats qualified for and competed in national championships.
But Payne says that success was overshadowed by what was going on behind the scenes, including alcohol and drug abuse by some team members.
In the summer of 2017, as Payne recounted to WTOC Investigates and as his lawyer said in documents filed in court, a student reported an alleged rape to him. The alleged victim was a teammate.
“There was a sexual assault that was reported to me. In that particular case, it dealt with a rape,” Payne said. “There’s a duty that I need to do as a coach, which is not to question or try to get all the facts of, you know, what may have happened or not happened.”
Payne says that at that point, he reported the alleged rape to SCAD, which SCAD denies.
Lawsuit and confidentiality agreement
SCAD fired Payne in March 2018. He filed a lawsuit against the school in 2020, alleging he was fired because of his race and in retaliation for reporting racial discrimination.
Though his wrongful termination suit was not based on the claim about the alleged rape, the incident does appear in a filing from the lawsuit.
In response to the lawsuit, SCAD filed a motion asking the judge to dismiss the case and rule it must be resolved in arbitration. SCAD also said Payne was not fired for race-related reasons, but for misconduct.
One of the exhibits attached to Payne’s response brief was a demand letter Payne’s attorney had previously sent to SCAD. According to that letter, “two members” of the crowd that were abusing drugs and alcohol “were accused of rape,” and Payne reported it to the school.
SCAD gave a confidentiality agreement to the student, who Payne says was not the victim or the alleged perpetrator but reported the rape to him, and to the student’s parents. The family gave Payne a copy of the agreement, which they did not sign, for use in his lawsuit.
In the brief, Payne’s attorney says the student “had lodged complaints with SCAD leadership raising concerns about some of the same issues Mr. Payne had sought the SCAD leadership’s help in resolving,” though the brief does not say what those issues were.
The confidentiality agreement itself says SCAD investigated “complaints” made by the student against several members of the fishing team under several policies, including its sexual misconduct policy, and found no violations.
It offers the student a $36,000 scholarship. In exchange, the family would give up their right to sue SCAD. It would also bar the family from making negative statements about SCAD, and would require them to keep “the facts and circumstances concerning” the agreement confidential, forever.
“Essentially, it was offering money in exchange for silence,” Payne said.
SCAD denies Payne ever reported the alleged rape to anyone at SCAD before he was fired, and says SCAD maintains a strict policy against retaliating against anyone who comes forward with concerns. The SCAD employee Payne says he reported the alleged rape to denies that Payne reported it to him.
A source close to the situation says a student reported the alleged rape to SCAD in addition to “a multitude of far-ranging conduct issues” related to the fishing team. Emails provided by the source show SCAD’s Title IX department reached out to the alleged victim, but the source says the student chose not to pursue a complaint.
The source would not confirm whether the student who reported the alleged rape was the student SCAD gave the confidentiality agreement to.
SCAD did not respond to multiple requests for comment on the confidentiality agreement.
WTOC Investigates reached out to the family that was given the confidentiality agreement by SCAD. The family declined to comment.
In 2021, a federal judge ordered that Payne had to bring his claim against SCAD in arbitration, citing an arbitration agreement Payne signed when he was first hired. A source close to the situation says Payne never filed the arbitration.
Payne says that as a former SCAD student, the situation has been difficult to accept, but he felt he had to get what happened on the public record.
“I still sit today hoping that nothing else is continuing to happen... as a parent myself, I wouldn’t want anyone in my family, or anyone else’s family, to have to deal with it,” Payne said.
SCAD’s response
SCAD says the incidents covered in WTOC Investigates’ reporting are “separate incidents” that involved “entirely different circumstances,” but each one was addressed “based on the information available and applicable to university policies.”
A spokesperson for SCAD provided a statement to WTOC Investigates:
“While we are limited in what we can say due to FERPA protections and student privacy and security policies, we can clearly confirm that SCAD is not under any assessment or investigation by The U.S. Department of Education’s Clery Act Compliance Division. The last inquiry by the department occurred in 2022 when a Clery Compliance Division staff member inquired about SCAD’s emergency notification processes. SCAD has provided all the necessary information and did not receive any additional questions or meeting requests. Based on our last communication and current understanding, the Department of Education found SCAD was in full compliance and the assessment resulted in no findings.
“We want to reassure our students, families, and community that the Savannah College of Art and Design has robust policies, procedures, and practices to meet all Title IX and Clery Act requirements. All SCAD faculty, staff, and contract employees are required to complete annual Title IX and Clery Act training. All employees are required to immediately report any information they have about suspected Title IX violations, including dating violence, domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
“SCAD educates students about Title IX and overall safety as soon as they arrive on campus, along with access to resources. SCAD encourages students to seek law enforcement intervention and assistance, if and when needed. This education continues throughout their time at SCAD. We want every student at SCAD to feel safe coming forward with any concerns and to know that they will be heard, supported, and taken seriously.”
Recent Posts











